On Sunday 26 November, doctors visited the home of Sheikh Isa Qassim, the spiritual leader of Bahrain’s Shia Muslim population, to assess the state of his health. He was found to be in constant pain and in need of emergency surgery due. After having his citizenship revoked in June 2016, Sheikh Qassim had been confined to his home under de facto house arrest, and has been wary of seeking health care for fear of being deported. However, in the past couple of days, the Sheikh’s health has worsened sharply, leading to the visit from doctors.
In June 2016, Bahraini authorities administratively revoked Sheikh Isa Qassim’s citizenship without any legal proceedings. Then, in May 2017, a court charged him in absentia with fraud stemming from the collection of khums – tithes paid by Shia that are used by the community to take care of the poor and disadvantaged. At the conclusion of the trial, the court convicted Sheikh Qassim of his charges and sentenced him to one year in prison while also fining him over $250,000, although he was not incarcerated.
Sheikh Qassim, who is over 70-years-old, suffers from a number of health issues. He is reportedly in continuous pain and excreting blood, which independent doctors have attributed to a groin hernia. He also suffers from high blood pressure, diabetes, and a form of heart disease. Due to his poor health, his family has pleaded with officials to have non-government healthcare professionals allowed to visit him and assess his health in his home in the village of Diraz. The only treatment for Sheikh Qassim’s condition is immediate surgery, but in order to receive the surgery, he must leave his house and risk potential deportation.
Diraz has been under a de factosiege since the government revoked Sheikh Qassim’s citizenship in June 2016, when his supporters rallied to his side in a mass, peaceful sit-in to protect him from deportation. The government responded by erecting barriers around the village and restricting access to residents only. Then, on 21 December 2016, security forces attacked the peaceful protesters, surrounding them with at least a dozen police vehicles and firing tear gas cans into the demonstrators. On 26 January 2017, security forces used live ammunition against the protesters, fatally shooting 18-year-old Mustafa Hamdan in the head. More recently, on 23 May 2017, security forces again attacked the protesters with tear gas and shotguns before denying dozens of wounded civilians access to hospitals and medical care. This latest attack resulted in five dead and at least 286 arrested, making it the bloodiest security force action since before 2011.
The announcement of Sheikh Qassim’s denaturalization has been met with international condemnation. On 20 June 2016, the United States Department of State released a statement saying, “We are alarmed by the Government of Bahrain’s decision to revoke the citizenship of prominent Shia cleric, Sheikh Isa Qassim. We remain deeply troubled by the Government of Bahrain’s practice of withdrawing the nationality of its citizens arbitrarily, the overall precedent that this case could establish, and the risk that individuals may be rendered stateless. Our concern is further magnified by reports that Sheikh Qassim was unable to respond to the accusations against him before this decision was taken, or challenge the decision through a transparent legal process.” The State Department’s 2016 Country Report on Human Rights and the US Commission on International Religious Freedom’s (USCIRF) 2016 annual report echo Kirby’s concern, citing Sheikh Qassim’s case as one of particular interest. USCIRF’s report adds that his case is part of an increased campaign of judicial harassment targeting Shia clerics, “mostly on unfounded or unsubstantiated charges.”
The government’s persecution and judicial harassment of Shia clerics is part of Bahrain’s targeting of important Shia figures and broader sectarian discrimination. ADHRB has documented this discrimination in tworeports, noting that government discrimination extends into the media, cultural, political, economic, and religious facets of Bahraini society. The United Nation’s (UN) independent experts have also taken note of Bahrain’s systematic discrimination against its Shia majority population.
In August 2016, five UN Special Procedure mandate holders issued a joint statement urging Bahrain to “end the persecution of Shias” and to “stop such arbitrary arrests or summons and release all those who have been detained for exercising their rights.” The UN also urged the Bahraini authorities “not resort to repressive measures and … to enter into dialogue with all relevant parties in order to prevent unnecessary conflict or violence.” Nine Special Procedure mandate holders expanded on this statement ahead of the March 2017 session of the Human Rights Council in a communication to the Bahraini government. In the communication, the Special Rapporteurs decried “the systematic persecution and repression of the Shia population, [including] religious leaders… in Bahrain based on their religion or belief.”
Bahrain must address the widespread international condemnation of its discriminatory policies and seriously reform its legal system in response to concerns by the US and UN. The government must additionally halt its practice of arbitrarily and administratively revoking the citizenship of prominent Bahraini religious and political figures. It must further drop all charges against Sheikh Isa Qassim, reinstate his citizenship, lift his de facto house arrest, and allow him full access to adequate health care.